Amazon's Black Friday deals are questioned in a new report, and the company is named in the story. · Consumer Cyclical
Amazon is named in the MarketWatch story questioning its Black Friday deals [4]. Between the close on November 16 ($257.75) and the close on November 17 ($257.89), its shares rose 0.05%, a coincidence in time that does not show the report had any effect.
Price between closes
$257.75 → $257.89Close of November 16 and November 17
Fair value (ATLAS)
$283.95Fair range: $124.88 to $373.41The price ($257.89) is 9.2% below that figure.
Chance of a rise in 1 month
50%Probability of closing higher than today within 21 sessions.Normal range: half of the scenarios end between $242.03 and $274.87; 9 in 10, between $216.22 and $307.69.
UK clothing and home retailer whose sales are heavily shaped by the Black Friday trading period. · Consumer Cyclical
Next is a UK clothing and home retailer whose sales are heavily shaped by the Black Friday trading period; it is included for its activity in the sector, not because the event affects it. Its shares fell 1.28% between the close on November 16 (£160.45) and the close on November 17 (£158.40). Its dividend yield is 3.93%.
Price between closes
£160.45 → £158.40Close of November 16 and November 17
Fair value (ATLAS)
£168.22Fair range: £139.94 to £279.49The price (£158.40) is 5.8% below that figure: close to its fair value.
Chance of a rise in 1 month
52%Probability of closing higher than today within 21 sessions.Normal range: half of the scenarios end between £152.53 and £165.64; 9 in 10, between £141.78 and £178.20.
UK sports fashion retailer that typically runs discounts during the Black Friday trading period. · Consumer Cyclical
JD Sports Fashion is a UK sports fashion retailer that typically runs discounts during the Black Friday trading period; it is included for its activity in the sector, not because the event affects it. Its shares fell 0.11% between the close on November 16 (£0.952) and the close on November 17 (£0.951). Its dividend yield is 1.34%.
Price between closes
£0.952 → £0.951Close of November 16 and November 17
Chance of a rise in 1 month
50%Probability of closing higher than today within 21 sessions.Normal range: half of the scenarios end between £0.893 and £1.01; 9 in 10, between £0.799 and £1.13.
S&P 500 between the same closes (November 16 and November 17): 7,416.59 → 7,340.53 points, −1.03%.
What happened
The BBC and Surrey Police both warn that Black Friday and the run-up to Christmas bring more online fraud, including fake websites and impersonating messages [1][3]. A separate MarketWatch headline asks whether Amazon's Black Friday deals really save shoppers money [4].
The BBC says this month's Black Friday and the tax return deadline at the end of January are both opportunities for fraudsters, because people are more likely to expect emails and texts at this time of year. It says fraudsters impersonate genuine organisations and retailers and push victims towards fake websites to steal personal information [1].
Surrey Police's fraud prevention team says fraudsters increase activity as Black Friday, Cyber Monday and Christmas shopping approach. It describes professional-looking websites and social media adverts offering popular products at heavily discounted prices, and says some shoppers receive counterfeit goods or nothing at all [3].
The same police notice says fraudsters send emails and text messages that appear to come from trusted retailers or delivery companies, and that people selling items online may be targeted by payment scams [3]. A CornishStuff headline also refers to Black Friday scams and Cornwall shoppers [2].
MarketWatch published a piece headlined: Do Amazon's Black Friday deals really save you money? A new report casts doubt [4].
What ATLAS data show
ATLAS model estimates are available for two of the three companies. For Amazon, the fair value estimate is $283.95 (range $124.88 to $373.41), with the price 9.18% below that value. For Next, the estimate is £168.22 (range £139.94 to £279.49), with the price 5.84% below it. These are model estimates, not promises, and the wide ranges show considerable uncertainty. No fair value estimate is shown for JD Sports Fashion.
Two moves close together in time do not mean one caused the other, and the scam warnings are not tied to any share price. Figures come from market closes and may change.
What you get with ATLAS
Fair value of each company, with its range, against today's price.
Chance of a rise in 1 month and the normal price range, from a calibrated model.
Earnings: next date, estimated EPS and surprise history.
Dividends and alerts by email when a company reports.
Why do police warn about scams around Black Friday?
Surrey Police says fraudsters increase their activity as Black Friday and Christmas shopping approach, using fake websites, deceptive adverts and convincing messages [3].
What did Amazon's share price do between November 16 and 17?
Amazon's close rose 0.05%, from $257.75 on November 16 to $257.89 on November 17. This is a coincidence in time, not a proven link to the report [4].
Closing prices, fair value, probabilities, earnings and dividends: ATLAS own data as of November 18, 2026. How we calculate fair value.
Information, not advice. This content is informational and is not an investment recommendation or an offer to buy or sell securities. ATLAS estimates come from statistical models using public data, can be wrong, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Disclaimer
ATLAS Signals
ATLAS Signals, every week
The week in the market, three stocks on ATLAS’s radar and what comes next. Get it every Monday.
By subscribing you agree to receive ATLAS Signals by email every Monday. You can unsubscribe with one click at any time. Privacy